Benchmark Rates First Internet Bancorp (INBK) buy

Benchmark analyst Brett Rabatin maintains a buy rating for INBK, aiming for a $33 price target, a 25.43% upside from the current price.

By EarningsIQ Research Desk · Published Jun 25, 2026, 6:00 AM EDT · Updated Jun 26, 2026, 2:01 AM EDT

Reviewed by automated data checks against the source data. How we make and check alerts

Benchmark rated First Internet Bancorp ($INBK) "buy" with a $33 price target on June 25, 2026.

Since the rating, $INBK is up 2.8% after 1 week, down 3.3% after 1 month and down 6.0% to date (from the $27.29 close on Jun 25, 2026).

INBK First Internet Bancorp

$25.66 +26.53% year to date

Daily close · Oct 16, 2026

Key Points

Benchmark's Brett Rabatin reiterated a buy rating on INBK with a $33 price target on June 25, 2026.
Benchmark's $33 price target implies 25.43% upside from First Internet Bancorp's ($INBK) current $26.31 share price.
INBK shares were trading around $26.31 on Thursday, with active institutional interest from several funds.
Insiders at INBK, including Christian Justin and Aasif Bade, purchased shares on May 18, 2026.

Get $INBK trade alerts by text

We text you when insiders, Congress or big funds trade $INBK. Free.

Not investment advice. EarningsIQ is not a registered investment adviser, and this automated First Internet Bancorp alert may contain errors. Disclosures

Benchmark analyst Brett Rabatin reiterated a buy rating on INBK, setting a price target of $33. This update came on June 25, 2026, as the stock traded near $26.31 on Thursday.

Analyst rating track record

Benchmark vs. the S&P 500

YTD return -18.21% hypothetical

All-time return -31.47% S&P 500 +22.43%

vs. S&P 500 -53.90% behind the index

Hypothetical returns from Benchmark's disclosed trades, not real profit or advice. How we model this.

Other Institutional Activity in INBK

BlackRock, Inc. reduced its holdings in INBK by 51,658 shares, ending with 778,524 shares valued at about $15.87 million, marking a 6.2% decrease. Heartland Advisors Inc saw a 33.4% increase in its stake, adding 96,305 shares for a total of 384,900 shares worth approximately $7.84 million. Dimensional Fund Advisors LP decreased its position by 55,774 shares, now holding 375,809 shares valued at $7.66 million, a 12.9% reduction. Aegis Financial Corp boosted its holdings by 103,941 shares to 354,261 shares, valued at $7.22 million, representing a 41.5% increase. Vanguard Capital Management LLC opened a new position with 336,248 shares valued at $6.85 million.

First Internet Bancorp Stock Down 5.3%

Shares of INBK traded near $26.31 on Thursday. The company has seen active trading and interest from various institutional investors.

12-month forecast

$INBK price target

First Internet Bancorp daily closes and this analyst's $33 target. Not advice.

Insider Buying and Selling at First Internet Bancorp

Several insiders at INBK, including Christian Justin, Aasif Bade, John Keach Jr, Joseph Fenech, Michele Raines, and Jean Wojtowicz, purchased 2,416 shares each on May 18, 2026. These transactions were not made under a pre-planned trading program.

Analysts Set New Price Targets

On June 25, 2026, Benchmark initiated coverage on INBK with a buy rating and a $33 price target. Previously, on May 1, 2026, Piper Sandler and Keefe, Bruyette & Woods maintained hold ratings with targets of $24.0. Earlier in the year, Piper Sandler had maintained a hold rating with a target of $23.5 on January 30, 2026.

Bottom Line

Benchmark's reaffirmation of its buy rating and a $33 target highlights confidence in INBK's potential. As institutional and insider activities show varied interest, investors watch these signals closely. Remember, 13F filings and analyst ratings are backward-looking and may not reflect current market conditions.